Womp, womp! Product Fail: Maybelline Define-A-Brow Eyebrow Pencil

Hate it when I don't do thorough research on a product, end up liking it, but then disliking it.

Bought this:

Heard good things about it and definitely cheaper than the Anastasia Brow Wiz I have been eyeing.

Filled in this:

Albeit it isn't the right tone for me, but it applied beautifully! 

Then looked at the ingredients:

PARABENS! :( *sigh* Back to the store this goes and I'll probably get the Anastasia instead since it does not contain parabens, sulfates or pthalates.